When the CCP Attacks — Part Two: A Military Analysis of Taiwan's Defense

When the CCP Attacks — Part Two: A Military Analysis of Taiwan's Defense

The opening recounts rumors from Part One — reason enough to skip that book.

After Chapter Two, real value emerges from Russia-Ukraine war context. Modern media ubiquity spread information; China initially mirrored Russian weapons and tactics. The author, collecting data post-war, offers analysis avoiding deep research — Russian-Ukrainian comparison with China-Taiwan scenarios using concrete conditions to evaluate rumors. New drone tactics show results; large drones are detected easily and costly; fast ones lose drone cheapness advantages; cheap ones move slowly and die to light weapons.

Small surveillance drones have limited range; Iran-bought drones have poor resolution and limited payload. By Russia-Ukraine war, propaganda exceeded actual effectiveness. Current usage emphasizes quantity, surveillance, or ambush.

The author urges military adopting drones: build logistics, equip squads with drones for reconnaissance.

Chapter Four: the author states history shows peace never rests on compromise — more compromise means more war. Once China believes infrastructure damage and population suffering force government surrender, war likelihood rises. This explains Chinese information campaigns framing Taiwan attack as binary — military is info-warfare too, with many gray zones.

The author disputes Chinese mining and urban warfare claims: mines put defenders passively on predetermined routes; Taiwan's towns are tougher than Ukraine's — missiles and shells struggle destroying structures, letting defenders shelter and ambush. China portrays post-landing victory as certain, ignoring multi-fold logistics and troops needed to hold gains.

Chapter Five: international dynamics shift. China's Taiwan strategy hinges on division, not sides. Escape binary thinking; whoever softens Taiwan's military defense for China's invasion is the concern.

Chapter Six discusses war prevention: reject black-and-white thinking. U.S. aid depends on context — key: Taiwanese build their own boundaries and consensus rather than demanding unconditional support. Civilians face biggest disruption 1–2 months pre-war — early damage aims to break morale. Three-month-plus wars: other nations' suffering spurs political pressure back on China (Russia saw wheat export pressure). Prolonged war finds civilian equilibrium. Preparedness: water filters, solar panels, emergency rations, first aid, medicine.

Concluding: Part Two outshines Part One — author's improved from Book One experience, and Russia-Ukraine provides better reference. Core: Taiwan's logic, military analysis via Ukraine comparison, neighboring states' attitudes, individual preparation — resources and psychology. Though the author holds positions, teaching focuses on physical preparation and psychological resilience, plus building Taiwanese consensus. This logic applies even to interpersonal dealings.

war #preparedness

Comments

Loading comments…

Leave a Comment