When the CCP Attacks — Part Two: A Military Analysis of Taiwan's Defense
The opening recounts rumors from Part One — reason enough to skip that book.
After Chapter Two, real value emerges from Russia-Ukraine war context. Modern media ubiquity spread information; China initially mirrored Russian weapons and tactics. The author, collecting data post-war, offers analysis avoiding deep research — Russian-Ukrainian comparison with China-Taiwan scenarios using concrete conditions to evaluate rumors. New drone tactics show results; large drones are detected easily and costly; fast ones lose drone cheapness advantages; cheap ones move slowly and die to light weapons.
Small surveillance drones have limited range; Iran-bought drones have poor resolution and limited payload. By Russia-Ukraine war, propaganda exceeded actual effectiveness. Current usage emphasizes quantity, surveillance, or ambush.
The author urges military adopting drones: build logistics, equip squads with drones for reconnaissance.
Chapter Four: the author states history shows peace never rests on compromise — more compromise means more war. Once China believes infrastructure damage and population suffering force government surrender, war likelihood rises. This explains Chinese information campaigns framing Taiwan attack as binary — military is info-warfare too, with many gray zones.
The author disputes Chinese mining and urban warfare claims: mines put defenders passively on predetermined routes; Taiwan's towns are tougher than Ukraine's — missiles and shells struggle destroying structures, letting defenders shelter and ambush. China portrays post-landing victory as certain, ignoring multi-fold logistics and troops needed to hold gains.
Chapter Five: international dynamics shift. China's Taiwan strategy hinges on division, not sides. Escape binary thinking; whoever softens Taiwan's military defense for China's invasion is the concern.
Chapter Six discusses war prevention: reject black-and-white thinking. U.S. aid depends on context — key: Taiwanese build their own boundaries and consensus rather than demanding unconditional support. Civilians face biggest disruption 1–2 months pre-war — early damage aims to break morale. Three-month-plus wars: other nations' suffering spurs political pressure back on China (Russia saw wheat export pressure). Prolonged war finds civilian equilibrium. Preparedness: water filters, solar panels, emergency rations, first aid, medicine.
Concluding: Part Two outshines Part One — author's improved from Book One experience, and Russia-Ukraine provides better reference. Core: Taiwan's logic, military analysis via Ukraine comparison, neighboring states' attitudes, individual preparation — resources and psychology. Though the author holds positions, teaching focuses on physical preparation and psychological resilience, plus building Taiwanese consensus. This logic applies even to interpersonal dealings.
Comments
Loading comments…
Leave a Comment